What is worth learning?
Affected
Racial Trauma
Racist Incidents
Isolation
Harm
School
Curriculum Violence
Though these words don't necessarily flow and some may not see the connection between them, this poem really speaks to me. I chose an excerpt from the article and blocked out every word but the ones that made me uncomfortable. Victims of racial trauma and curriculum violence are uncomfortable so my goal with this poem was to make the reader feel just a small part of what students of color feel everyday when they walk into school.
Hello Riley,
ReplyDeleteI believe your poem resembles this module well. I agree that your poem allows the reader to feel what minorities and students have felt at school as they experienced racial trauma and curriculum violence. I also used the word racial trauma and curriculum violence. A few words that I also used were fail, normalize, nonphysical injury, and manifests. I believe that teachers are trying to come from a goof intention on teaching these lessons, but fail to realize that reaanacting and reliving the trauma and past for these children are detrimental to their mental health and learning. There are other ways to portray and deliver the curriculum. In the article, ending curriculum violence, it mentions, " Most importantly, it is the wrong reaction for teachers to avoid teaching Black
histories for fear of perpetuating curriculum violence." It should not be breezed through and brushed off like my experience as a child, but it should not also be used as a way for children to experience and reenact certain situations either. How would you go about delivering a subject that makes students or you uncomfortable? How would you ease this feeling towards this subject regarding you students and yourself?
Hi Riley! My poem was similar to yours and didn’t flow very well. Here is mine:
ReplyDeleteReclaim our schools
Real learning
Critically examine
Curriculum violence
Reflective and reflexive
Antiracist
Resistance
Fear of perpetuating curriculum violence
Remaining silent or choosing to omit certain elements of history has the same impact
Right thing by our students
Learn more and seek feedback from students
Review and revise
Reparations
Repair the harm that failed them.
I chose to go with a couple phrases/ sentences because I felt that what they had to say was so important and I didn’t want to leave them out of m Blackout Poem. I really liked the way you chose to create this poem. I was a little confused, but you had a great method of choosing only the words that made you feel uncomfortable. I also liked your idea of intentionally making readers uncomfortable so they can feel just how the students do everyday in school.
Hey there Riley! I think your poem really encapsulates the ideas we learned about in this module. These words invoke a real emotional response when reading them and that really sums up the emotions that many of today's students go through. The intentional usage of these words lets the readers see through the student's perspective, even if just for a moment. As a reader, my first thought was, "If these few words feel bad to me, what does a life time of it feel like to them?". This is a reality for our students, our children, and it is not one I want to be a part of.
ReplyDeleteHello Riley, your poem was very catching to me. I believe that your poem shows a great reflection of what was demonstrated within the module. I too agree that your poem puts the reader in a position that students of color get put into. Many feel that the color of their skin is not the voice of them. But I’m todays society, by looking at the color of my skin we are judged in many ways before we even open our mouths. I myself have been in uncomfortable and racial incidents that left me unsure of myself. With your poem you were able to throw and create words that are effected by many today. All in all, I like the idea of using words that made you feel uncomfortable because just by this you were able to gain a little confidence back. As future teachers, we have to make sure every child no matter the color of their skin feel both confident and comfortable both inside and outside the classroom.
ReplyDeleteHey Riley! I believe that you did a great job at creating a poem that resembles the text. I love how you stated that you blacked out all of the words, except for the ones that made you uncomfortable! This is so important, because we must confront the topics that make us uncomfortable head on so that we can become better educators. In my poem, I included the words, " do the right thing by our students, review and revise, educational reparations and repair the harm." These words stood out to me because they emphasize the responsibility that educators have to put an end to curriculum violence. Overall, I like the contrast of our poems. I focused on the words that are the solution to the problem, while you highlighted the harm that curriculum violence causes. It was interesting to see the difference between our poems, but also see how powerful the message of yours was!
ReplyDeleteHi Riley! I loved seeing your blackout poem and think that taking out all words except ones that make others uncomfortable is a great way to show the meaning of this unit. It is so important as teachers that we do not stray our children away from history even if it is uncomfortable. It is of course unfortunate that history makes people feel this way but history is the truth and we cannot just avoid it. Did you see the hidden curriculum video? I loved that this video talked about this hidden curriculum being more important than the instructional. I think how we treat students can really affect how they will treat themselves. This can coincide with the uncomfortableness you mentioned in your post. That video has made me very self aware of the things I saw in front of students and how I will teach them differently in the future. Making sure students feel comfortable in your classroom can help change the uncomfortableness that comes with teaching these harder topics.
ReplyDelete